Stone vs. Concrete for Cobblestone Landing Restoration

It's a confusing issue, but to simplify --

1. Everybody in Memphis (including the RDC and the Memphis Landmarks Commission staff) says they'd rather use real stone to repair the Cobblestone Landing infill section. That's most of the light gray area in the aerial illustration.

It's marked "cobblestones" in the cross-section illustration.
(click illustrations to enlarge)

2. But, according to Landmarks staff and the RDC, somebody in Nashville told us we couldn't use real stone, that it would not meet the historic preservation guidelines.
Read more »

Labels:

Restoration Project Will Fix Drainage

The Riverfront Development Corporation (RDC) has committed to correct any drainage problems that may be damaging the Cobblestone Landing.

The work will be part of the $6M federally
funded Cobblestone Landing Restoration Project that the RDC will be overseeing for the City. They told the Memphis Downtown Commission Design Review Board, TN Department of Transportation, and TN State Historic Preservation Officer that the situation will be assessed, and, if storm water run-off problems are found, they will be corrected.

The photos illustrate potential problem areas.

For more information about Cobblestone Landing Restoration Project, click HERE.

Labels:

Cobblestone Landing Restoration - Do it with Excellence

ALL OF THESE NEED TO BE CHECKED, NOT JUST 2

Recognized by the National Park Service for the important role it has played in American history, the Memphis Cobblestone Landing is being restored. The Riverfront Development Corporation (RDC) will present their revised restoration plan to the Memphis Landmarks Commission Thursday, Apr. 26, at 5 pm at City Hall (125 N. Main, Conference Rm. A, 4th floor) and to the Downtown Memphis Commission Design Review Board on Wed., May 2 at 5 pm at DMC's office, 114 N. Main Str.) Both meetings are open to the public. To submit comments to DRB, e-mail Brett Roler roler@downtownmemphis.com (575-0540); to Landmarks, fill out their automatic e-mail form HERE.

Representatives from FfOR have met with RDC representatives, reviewed the proposed design and materials, and, in response to a request from the RDC, we've summarized our opinion about the revised proposals for both the Cobblestone Landing and Beale Street Landing projects.
Read more »

Labels:

History of Memphis Cobblestone Landing & Why it's Important to Preserve It

Judith Rutschman's interview with Virginia McLean and Judith Johnson for Sierra Club Nature of Conservation.

Memphis Cobblestone Landing from Chickasaw Group on Vimeo.

Labels:

To: Memphis

From: National Park Service
a present to our future from our past.

It's been a City goal since 1995, and on Dec. 12 Mayor Wharton received the good news: the National Park Service has recognized the national significance of the Memphis Cobblestone Landing, elevating it from local to national significance and opening the door for the Landing to become a National Historic Landmark like Beale Street, Chucalissa, Graceland, and Sun Studio.

Raising the historic and current Landing's status was unanimously recommended to the Park Service by the Memphis Landmarks Commission and the TN Historical Commission with the support of the Shelby County delegation and Rep. Steve Cohen. The nomination was prepared by architectural historian Judith Johnson under a grant from the Crawford Howard Foundation to Friends for Our Riverfront.

Labels:

Cobblestone Landing - A Memphis Icon & Living History

Joe Spake captures the Landing's beauty and the tragedy of its neglect.

Labels:

Bearden Video Documents Importance of Cobblestone Landing

Memphis filmmaker Willy Bearden has documented many of Memphis's most cherished places. His new video, "The Memphis Cobblestone Landing - A Community Conversation," captures the significance of the landing - the role it has played in the development of our community and its place in the history of America.

Memphis historian Dr. Beverly Bond, Memphis Mayor AC Wharton and architectural historian Judith Johnson discuss the significance and future of the Memphis Cobblestone Landing.


Willy Bearden and his popular documentaries, books, full-length film "One Came Home," Legacy collection of Memphis photographs, and major role in The Delta-Everything Southern Conference have captured the hearts of Memphians. For a 2008 "Memphis Magazine" interview with Bearden, click HERE.

Labels:

Memphis Cobblestone Landing Nominated for National Listing

The National Park Service is evaluating the Memphis Cobblestone Landing for individual listing in the National Register of Historic Places. Approval would be another plus for downtown Memphis, a point of pride for our community, and an economic boon for cultural tourism.

Unanimously recommended by the Memphis Landmarks Commission and the TN Historical Commission, the nomination was prepared by architectural historian Judith Johnson, a founding member of Friends for Our Riverfront, and underwritten by a grant from the Crawford-Howard Foundation. It focuses on the Landing’s role as a transportation hub for the trading of cotton and the economic, political, and social contribution of African Americans in the development of the U.S. as a global trading power.

As Mayor A C Wharton says the Landing is not just old; it tells a story of national importance that has not been told previously. The nomination has also been supported by the Shelby County State Legislative Delegation and by U.S. Congressman Steve Cohen. Rep. Barbara Cooper, in whose district the Landing is located, attended and spoke on behalf of the Landing's significance to the TN Historical Commission Review Board.

This place matters. As Dr. Beverly Bond says, “it gives the long historical perspective ... and explains to our children what Memphis was and how we got where we are today.”

For more than 100 years, cotton comprised over 50% of the GNP of the U. S. and fueled the Industrial Revolution worldwide. It was as important in terms of wealth, politics, and history in the 19th century as oil is today. Read more »

Labels:

Design Review Board Stands Up for Restoration of Cobblestone Landing


Center City Commission Design Review Board unanimously prefers continued access to water and sends RDC back to drawing board on Cobblestone Landing plan.

Members of the Design Review Board recognized the uniqueness and significance of the historic site and the importance of the Landing's connection to the water. Much of their opposition was to the construction of a barrier wall of riprap along the Landing's shoreline, a design that would alter the dynamic of the waterfront and cut-off access to the water. "It is a Landing," one member stated in summary, and the consensus was that if this is a restoration project the design fails to meet the objective.

Click HERE for Commercial Appeal coverage by Wayne Risher.

Labels:

Mistake Memphis Escaped

Denise Scott Brown, one of the most influential architects of the twentieth century, talks about her work in Memphis --
* the beauty of our riverfront,
* the incredible sense of history on the Memphis Cobblestone Landing, and
* how we barely escaped the mistake of building a freeway across them.

Labels:

A Sense of Place - A City of Choice





















Ultimately quality of life will be determined by five senses: the sense of place, the sense of evolution, the sense of ownership, the sense of identity and the sense of community itself.

Donovan Rypkema, economic development and preservation consultant

How we treat our riverfront - it's past, present, and future - is important.

Labels:

1 family has captained local fleet and given Memphis proud tradition


Photos of Dale & William Lozier by Amie Vanderford.

For the late Capt. Thomas Meredith Meanley, his daughter Dale Meanley Lozier, and now his grandson, William Lozier, a love of the river has provided Memphians and visitors a trip on the “Mighty Mississippi.” They’ve built, owned, and operated a fleet of boats that have headed out from the Cobblestone Landing for 50 years. And they’ve done it with little support from the City.

After a stint in the Navy, Capt. Meanley, the grandson of newspaper tycoon E. W. Scripps, moved to Memphis and (click read more below)

Read more »

Labels:

Floating Restaurant - Memphis an Innovative Leader

Self-service grocery stores, overnight package delivery, and a national chain of quality motels all put Memphis on the map as a place for innovation. So did ideas for a floating hotel and the floating restaurant, Sunset Cafe, at the foot of the Cobblestone Landing.

In the 1980s, you could walk down the cobblestones, sit on a floating restaurant, eat a hamburger, and drink a beer any day or night of the week. Memphis was even thinking about adding a floating hotel. Click “read more” to see what’s happened.
Read more »

Labels:

FfOR's position and recommendations

Keep the Landing Open - This Place Matters

FfOR supports restoration, maintenance, and increased public use of the Cobblestone Landing as a vibrant, active, working dock. It is both the city's historic and current riverboat landing and one of our most significant landmarks. Its cultural significance and location in the center of the riverfront make it a key component in downtown's revitalization and an important asset for recreation, commerce, and historic tourism.

The current proposal to use riprap and a bulkhead capped with a sidewalk to stabilize the landing will permanently close the site for boat use and leave the riverfront with a vast empty field of cobblestones in its center.

How should the landing be restored?

The answer may lie just across the harbor at the Mud Island River Park boat ramp. It copied the Cobblestone Landing, and the constant slope allows people and boats to reach the water at all water levels.

The original design of the Cobblestone Landing works. As the 2002 RDC Master Plan said, "The Cobblestones are amphibious in nature, part land, part water, and are the perfect form for boat landings given the river’s rising and falling tendency.”

Restoration of the Cobblestone Landing should:

• Get the goal right – Top Priority: Restore, Maintain, and Open it Up as a free navigable site for people to use and enjoy. Add other features only if we have extra money and they don’t have an adverse impact on the historic property.

• Follow the guidelines of the 1996 Preservation Plan. If there is a need for any change to its recommendations or the landing’s original design, involve specialists in historic preservation, archaeologists, river users, environmental experts, and the public.

• Repair drainage problems, discourage dredging close to the bank, plan for future maintenance.

• Brag about our authentic historic Cobblestone Landing. Nominate the site as a National Historic Landmark. “Today of all the great landings in the MS River basin, the Memphis landing is acknowledged to be the best preserved."



Read more:

  • The proposed project and the current situation

  • The 1996 Preservation Plan and recommendations

  • Cultural and historical significance of our Cobblestone Landing
  • Labels:

    Proposed Project/Current Situation

    Since 1996, the City has received $13M in State and Federal funds to restore the historic Cobblestone Landing - $7M approved by the State in 1996; $6M approved in subsequent years by the Federal government.



    Almost $4M of the money was spent to build a wall and sidewalk along Riverside Drive and steps from the sidewalk down to the landing.



    But the landing itself was not restored, repaired, or maintained and the wall has caused more problems and deterioration.

    The current proposed project will make some repairs and add utilities, sidewalks, and historic markers. Here's an illustration. Look carefully:


    Aerial view.


    Cross-section.

    Here's the river gauge that measures water levels. During the year, the water goes up and down about 50 feet:



    Here's the landing at high and low water:



    Here's approximately where the sidewalk will be. At 17 feet on the river gauge, it will be underwater at least half the year:



    Below the sidewalk, the project proposes to dredge the bank, alter the slope from gradual 1:6 to steeper 1:3 grade, and fill the area with riprap.



    People can't walk on riprap. Boats can't put-in or dock on riprap. This project shuts the landing down as a navigable site and creates a barrier between the land and water.



    It ignores all earlier plans for an active, vibrant Cobblestone Landing and eliminates the future potential for special use barges for things like restaurants, markets, or boat docks. It means no longer being able to board riverboat cruises here or skip rocks or any of the other things Memphians and visitors have long enjoyed on the Cobblestone Landing.



    Read more:

  • FfOR's position and recommendations

  • The 1996 Preservation Plan and recommendations

  • Cultural and historical significance of our Cobblestone Landing
  • Labels:

    Cultural & Historical Significance of our Cobblestone Landing


    Memphis is recognized as a distribution center for the world, and it all began at the river. Native Americans used the land along the river as a port 1,000 years ago followed by the Spanish, French, British, and early Americans. When Memphis was laid out in 1819, the public landing was designed into the fabric of the city.

    The MS River Basin drains 40% of the US and serves as a water highway connecting inland America together and to the world. Goods, people, and ideas all traveled by river, first by canoe, then flatboat, and later by steamboat.









    Starting in 1859, the Memphis public landing was paved with cobblestones quarried in seven states and laid by skilled Irish and German immigrants. It was a technological advance that ennabled the port to operate even in the muddiest times and Memphis to out-pace rival ports and become the cotton and hardwood lumber capital of the world. Even without proper maintenance, its design has withstood the test of time, and its permeable surface is environmentally sound today.


    The landing’s cultural significance is symbolized by a riverboat and appears on the City seal, flag, and even on downtown drain covers. It is the legendary place that James Hyter sang about in “Ole Man River” and where Davy Crockett left TN headed for the Alamo. It has been in continuous operation for 150 years and is listed on the National Register of Historic Places.


    Read more:

  • FfOR's position and recommendations

  • The proposed project and the current situation

  • The 1996 Preservation Plan and recommendations
  • Labels:

    How to Repair a Boat Landing?

    Boat landings, like all things, need maintenance and repair. Sloughing off at the toe of a landing is not a problem unique to the Cobblestone Landing. It's happening at the Wolf River landing in Shelby Farms Park, too.

    Because of the integrity of its original design, the Cobblestone Landing has been in continuous use for more than 150 years with insufficient maintenance. The RDC Masterplan described it as "the perfect form for boat landings given the river's rising and falling tendency."

    The City has received $13M in Federal and State funds to restore the landing. What's the correct way to do it -- the way that will repair, support easy future maintenance, and open the public boat landing up for people to use and enjoy in the future?

    Labels:

    Confused?

    Several people have said they left the RDC public meeting on Aug. 11 confused about the purpose of the meeting. We were told it wasn't a meeting to discuss design ideas. Then we were shown a plan to use riprap to repair the landing. That's not a viable design. People cannot walk on riprap. Boats are damaged by riprap. In fact, a couple of weeks ago a barge was damaged and sank because of the riprap at the edge of Tom Lee Park. To read about it in "The Flyer," click HERE.

    Labels:

    Blogger Takes Hard Look at Cobblestone Landing

    An independent blogger takes a tough look at the issues -- Cobbles under Glass? How stupid are we? Check it out - lots of interesting stuff. Click HERE.

    Labels:

    What about walking on cobblestones?

    Spiked heels not advised, but Gwyneth Paltrow did it.
    Michele Obama, in low heels, did it.


    Regular people, kids and grown-ups, do it.


    They do it all over the world.




    Segways and dancing permitted.

    Labels: